Home › NFL Season Pick Trends 2025-26 › Indianapolis Colts

Indianapolis Colts Pick Trends: 2025-26 Season

How often players in the poolsbyround NFL Season pool picked the Indianapolis Colts each week, and how those picks turned out.

Final numbers, updated

Quick answers

How often did pick'em players pick the Colts in the 2025-26 season?

In the 2025-26 season, the Colts got an average of 54% of the picks in their games, the 17th most of any NFL team.

How often did the Colts win when they're the most popular pick in the 2025-26 season?

In the 2025-26 season, the Colts were the most popular pick in 9 games and won 6 of them (67%).

Were the Colts overrated by pick'em players in the 2025-26 season?

A little. Players picked them an average of 54% of the time, and they won 8 of 17 games (47%).

How often did the Colts win as the underdog in the 2025-26 season?

In the 2025-26 season, the Colts were the underdog in 8 games and won 2 of 8 with a result. Players picked them an average of 28% of the time in those games.

Colts pick percentages by week

WeekOpponentPickedResult
Week 1vs. Miami DolphinsColts favored by 1.538%
Won
Week 2vs. Denver BroncosColts 1.5 point underdog42%
WonUpset
Week 3vs. Tennessee TitansColts favored by 4.583%
Won
Week 4vs. Los Angeles RamsColts 3.5 point underdog30%
Lost
Week 5vs. Las Vegas RaidersColts favored by 6.590%
Won
Week 6vs. Arizona CardinalsColts favored by 7.588%
Won
Week 7vs. Los Angeles ChargersColts 1.5 point underdog52%
WonUpset
Week 8vs. Tennessee TitansColts favored by 14.592%
Won
Week 9vs. Pittsburgh SteelersColts favored by 3.575%
LostUpset
Week 10vs. Atlanta FalconsColts favored by 6.592%
Won
Week 11Bye
Week 12vs. Kansas City ChiefsColts 3.5 point underdog42%
Lost
Week 13vs. Houston TexansColts favored by 4.577%
LostUpset
Week 14vs. Jacksonville JaguarsColts favored by 1.552%
LostUpset
Week 15vs. Seattle SeahawksColts 14.5 point underdog13%
Lost
Week 16vs. San Francisco 49ersColts 6.5 point underdog20%
Lost
Week 17vs. Jacksonville JaguarsColts 6.5 point underdog18%
Lost
Week 18vs. Houston TexansColts 10.5 point underdog11%
Lost

Picked is the percentage of Pick the Winner players who picked the Colts in that game.

Other NFL teams

Colts in other seasons

Play along

The NFL Season pool is free, with no ads. Play weekly or all season, on your own or in a league with your friends. Want an edge? Read our NFL Season pick'em strategy guide. For the whole season, see the 2025-26 NFL Season pick trends.

This web site is for entertainment purposes only. Terms of Use Privacy Statement
poolsbyround.com is not affiliated in any way with the NFL, NBA, WNBA, NHL, NCAA, MLB or FIFA. All team names and logos are copyright of their respective owners.