NFL Season Pick Percentages: Week 18, 2025-26

These are the Week 18 picks of 714 Pick the Winner entries in the poolsbyround NFL Season pool.

Final numbers, updated

Week 18 at a glance

  • The crowd went 9-7. The most-picked team won 9 of 16 games with a result.
  • Most popular pick: Buffalo Bills, picked by 94% of players (they won).
  • Biggest upset: Cleveland Browns, a 7.5 point underdog, beat Cincinnati Bengals, even though 86% of players picked Cincinnati Bengals.
  • Closest call: Carolina Panthers vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers, split 41% to 59%.

Every Week 18 game

Sorted by kickoff. The favorite is shown with its points, like −3.5. The bar shows the percentage of players who picked the more popular team.

GameMost pickedPickedResult
Carolina Panthers vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers −2.5Tampa Bay Buccaneers 59%
59%✓ Won
Seattle Seahawks −1.5 vs. San Francisco 49ersSan Francisco 49ers 64%
64%✗ Lost
New Orleans Saints vs. Atlanta Falcons −3.5Atlanta Falcons 74%
74%✓ Won
Cleveland Browns vs. Cincinnati Bengals −7.5Cincinnati Bengals 86%
86%✗ LostUnderdog won
Green Bay Packers vs. Minnesota Vikings −7.5Minnesota Vikings 61%
61%✓ Won
Dallas Cowboys −3.5 vs. NY GiantsDallas Cowboys 81%
81%✗ LostUnderdog won
Tennessee Titans vs. Jacksonville Jaguars −12.5Jacksonville Jaguars 89%
89%✓ Won
Indianapolis Colts vs. Houston Texans −10.5Houston Texans 89%
89%✓ Won
NY Jets vs. Buffalo Bills −7.5Buffalo Bills 94%
94%✓ Won
Detroit Lions vs. Chicago Bears −3.5Chicago Bears 71%
71%✗ LostUnderdog won
Los Angeles Chargers vs. Denver Broncos −12.5Denver Broncos 82%
82%✓ Won
Kansas City Chiefs −5.5 vs. Las Vegas RaidersKansas City Chiefs 67%
67%✗ LostUnderdog won
Arizona Cardinals vs. Los Angeles Rams −7.5Los Angeles Rams 92%
92%✓ Won
Miami Dolphins vs. New England Patriots −10.5New England Patriots 88%
88%✓ Won
Washington Commanders vs. Philadelphia Eagles −4.5Philadelphia Eagles 86%
86%✗ LostUnderdog won
Baltimore Ravens −3.5 vs. Pittsburgh SteelersBaltimore Ravens 59%
59%✗ LostUnderdog won

Beat the Spread picks

48 entries play in Beat the Spread leagues, picking which team will beat the spread instead of picking the winner. Their most popular picks went 7-9 this week.

GameMost pickedPickedBeat the spread?
Carolina Panthers vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers −2.5Tampa Bay Buccaneers 69%
69%✗ No
Seattle Seahawks −1.5 vs. San Francisco 49ersSan Francisco 49ers 60%
60%✗ No
New Orleans Saints vs. Atlanta Falcons −3.5Atlanta Falcons 58%
58%✗ No
Cleveland Browns vs. Cincinnati Bengals −7.5Cincinnati Bengals 53%
53%✗ No
Green Bay Packers vs. Minnesota Vikings −7.5Minnesota Vikings 51%
51%✓ Yes
Dallas Cowboys −3.5 vs. NY GiantsDallas Cowboys 71%
71%✗ No
Tennessee Titans vs. Jacksonville Jaguars −12.5Jacksonville Jaguars 56%
56%✓ Yes
Indianapolis Colts vs. Houston Texans −10.5Houston Texans 58%
58%✗ No
NY Jets vs. Buffalo Bills −7.5Buffalo Bills 91%
91%✓ Yes
Detroit Lions vs. Chicago Bears −3.5Chicago Bears 64%
64%✗ No
Los Angeles Chargers vs. Denver Broncos −12.5Denver Broncos 53%
53%✓ Yes
Kansas City Chiefs −5.5 vs. Las Vegas RaidersKansas City Chiefs 57%
57%✗ No
Arizona Cardinals vs. Los Angeles Rams −7.5Los Angeles Rams 87%
87%✓ Yes
Miami Dolphins vs. New England Patriots −10.5New England Patriots 66%
66%✓ Yes
Washington Commanders vs. Philadelphia Eagles −4.5Philadelphia Eagles 70%
70%✗ No
Baltimore Ravens −3.5 vs. Pittsburgh SteelersPittsburgh Steelers 60%
60%✓ Yes

The 2025-26 season

In the 2025-26 season, the team picked by the most players has won 178 of 271 games (66%). See the 2025-26 NFL Season pick trends for the crowd's favorite teams, overrated and underrated teams and the crowd's record each week.

Other weeks

Play along

The NFL Season pool is free, with no ads. Play weekly or all season, on your own or in a league with your friends. Want an edge? Read our NFL Season pick'em strategy guide. For the whole season, see the 2025-26 NFL Season pick trends.

This web site is for entertainment purposes only. Terms of Use Privacy Statement
poolsbyround.com is not affiliated in any way with the NFL, NBA, WNBA, NHL, NCAA, MLB or FIFA. All team names and logos are copyright of their respective owners.