Every week of the 2025-26 season, about 960 players made their picks in the poolsbyround NFL Season pool. Here are the patterns in their Pick the Winner picks, from the teams they picked most to the bandwagon teams.
The crowd's pick is the team most people picked in a game.
See Week 18 pick percentages
Final numbers, updated
Quick answers
What percentage of NFL games did the average pick'em player get right in the 2025-26 season?
In the 2025-26 season, the average Pick the Winner player in the poolsbyround NFL Season pool picked 61% of games right. Going with the most popular pick in every game would have been right 66% of the time.
How often did the most popular pick win in the 2025-26 season?
In the 2025-26 season, the team picked by the most players won 178 of 271 games (66%).
How often did a team picked by 90% of pick'em players win in the 2025-26 season?
In the 2025-26 season, teams picked by at least 90% of players in the poolsbyround NFL Season pool won 39 of 51 games (76%). Teams picked by 50% to 59% won 52% of the time.
Which NFL team did pick'em players pick the most in the 2025-26 season?
The Buffalo Bills, with an average of 83% of the picks in their games in the 2025-26 season.
Which NFL team was the most overrated by pick'em players in the 2025-26 season?
The Kansas City Chiefs. Players picked them an average of 60% of the time, but they won 6 of 17 games (35%).
How often did NFL underdogs win in the 2025-26 season?
In the 2025-26 season, underdogs won 92 of 271 games (34%), and players picked the underdog 25% of the time.
How often did NFL underdogs of 7 or more points win in the 2025-26 season?
In the 2025-26 season, underdogs of 7 or more points won 15 of 75 games (20%), and players picked them 11% of the time. Underdogs of less than 3 points won 40% of the time.
Do underdog points change how pick'em players pick in the 2025-26 season?
Yes. In the poolsbyround NFL Season pool, players in leagues with medium underdog points picked the underdog 27% of the time, compared with 23% in leagues with no underdog points.
What was the biggest pick'em upset of the 2025-26 season?
In Week 10, the Miami Dolphins beat the Buffalo Bills, even though 95% of players picked the Buffalo Bills.
The crowd's favorite teams
Players have picked the Buffalo Bills more than any other team, with an average of 83% of the picks in their games. They're 12-5 when they're the crowd's pick.
What percentage of games the average player gets right
In the 2025-26 season, the average Pick the Winner player has picked 61% of games right. Going with the most popular pick in every game would have been right 66% of the time, so following the crowd beats the average player.
In Week 18, players who picked every game got 9.2 of 16 right on average. The best score was 14 of 16, by 2 players.
Each bar is one week: the percentage of picks the average player got right. Finished weeks only, ties aren't counted.
Overrated and underrated teams
If the crowd were always right, a team picked by 70% of players in its games would win about 70% of them. These teams are the furthest off. The most overrated: the Kansas City Chiefs, picked by an average of 60% of players, but they won 6 of 17 games (35%). The most underrated: the Houston Texans, picked by an average of 49% of players, but they won 12 of 17 games (71%).
Overrated: picked more than they win
Underrated: win more than they're picked
Some leagues give extra points for underdog wins, which adds a little to underdogs' % of picks.
Biggest upsets of the season
Games where the most players picked the team that lost.
- Week 10: Miami Dolphins, a 9.5-point underdog, beat Buffalo Bills. 95% of players picked Buffalo Bills.
- Week 14: New Orleans Saints, a 8.5-point underdog, beat Tampa Bay Buccaneers. 94% of players picked Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
- Week 6: NY Giants, a 6.5-point underdog, beat Philadelphia Eagles. 92% of players picked Philadelphia Eagles.
- Week 9: Minnesota Vikings, a 8.5-point underdog, beat Detroit Lions. 92% of players picked Detroit Lions.
- Week 9: Carolina Panthers, a 13.5-point underdog, beat Green Bay Packers. 92% of players picked Green Bay Packers.
How often the crowd is right
In the 2025-26 season, the team picked by the most players has won 178 of 271 games (66%). Over the last 3 weeks, the crowd is 29-19 (60%), worse than its 67% in weeks 1 to 15.
When more players agree, how often they're right
A team picked by 51% of players and one picked by 85% both count as the crowd's pick, but they're not the same. When at least 90% of players picked the same team, that team won 76% of the time. When the vote was close, 50% to 59%, the crowd's pick won 52%.
| Picked by | Games | Crowd record | Won |
|---|
| 50–59% | 33 | 17-16 | 52% |
| 60–69% | 46 | 27-19 | 59% |
| 70–79% | 59 | 37-22 | 63% |
| 80–89% | 82 | 58-24 | 71% |
| 90% or more | 51 | 39-12 | 76% |
Games with a result, by the percentage of players who picked the more popular team.
Underdogs: how often they're picked, and how often they win
Players have picked the underdog 25% of the time in the 2025-26 season, and underdogs have won 92 of 271 games (34%). Underdogs win more often than players pick them.
% picked the underdog % underdogs won
The underdog is the team expected to lose, based on the game's point spread. Finished weeks only.
Small and big underdogs
A small underdog and a big one aren't the same pick. Underdogs of less than 3 points won 40% of the time, and underdogs of 10 or more points 7%. The biggest gap: underdogs of 3 to 6.5 points won 39% of the time, but players picked them only 23%.
| Underdog by | Games | Underdog won | Picked the underdog |
|---|
| Less than 3 points | 77 | 31 (40%) | 41% |
| 3 to 6.5 points | 119 | 46 (39%) | 23% |
| 7 to 9.5 points | 47 | 13 (28%) | 12% |
| 10 or more points | 28 | 2 (7%) | 9% |
Games with a result. Picked the underdog is the percentage of players who picked the underdog in those games.
Underdog points
Some poolsbyround leagues give extra points for picking an underdog that wins, and each league picks how many: none, low, medium or high. Players in leagues with medium underdog points picked the underdog 27% of the time, compared with 23% in leagues with no underdog points.
| Underdog points | Entries per week | Picked the underdog | Avg % right |
|---|
| None | 424 | 23% | 61% |
| Medium | 465 | 27% | 60% |
Medium includes players who aren't in a league, since it's the default.
Bandwagon teams: who the crowd is jumping on, and off
These teams are getting more, or fewer, of the picks in their games in Weeks 15 to 18 than in Weeks 1 to 14. The biggest climb: the Cincinnati Bengals, from 36% of the picks in their games to 77%. The biggest drop: the Indianapolis Colts, from 66% to 15%.
Picked more lately:
Cincinnati Bengals 36% to 77% | |
Houston Texans 40% to 79% | |
New Orleans Saints 18% to 50% | |
NY Giants 19% to 41% | |
Jacksonville Jaguars 50% to 72% | |
Tap a bar to see its number.
Picked less lately:
Indianapolis Colts 66% to 15% | |
Baltimore Ravens 68% to 42% | |
Los Angeles Chargers 70% to 46% | |
Washington Commanders 42% to 18% | |
Miami Dolphins 43% to 20% | |
Tap a bar to see its number.
Percentage of the picks in each team's games. Each small bar is one week: green the team won, red it lost, gray no result yet. A gap is a bye.
Pick percentages for every NFL team, by week
The percentage of players who picked each team, every week. Most picked teams first. Tap a team for its own page.
Darker means more players picked the team. A green outline means the team won, red means it lost. A dash is a bye. Scroll sideways to see every week.
Thursday, Sunday or Monday: when the crowd gets it right
The crowd's pick has won 52% of Thursday games, compared with 68% of Sunday games and 67% of Monday games. Thursday games, played on a short week, have been harder to pick than Sunday games.
| Kickoff day | Games | Crowd record | Right |
|---|
| Thursday | 21 | 11-10 | 52% |
| Saturday | 6 | 3-3 | 50% |
| Sunday | 221 | 150-71 | 68% |
| Monday | 21 | 14-7 | 67% |
Other seasons
Play along
The NFL Season pool is free, with no ads. Play weekly or all season, on your own or in a league with your friends. Want an edge? Read our NFL Season pick'em strategy guide.