NFL Season Pick Percentages: Week 5, 2025-26

These are the Week 5 picks of 970 Pick the Winner entries in the poolsbyround NFL Season pool.

Final numbers, updated

Week 5 at a glance

  • The crowd went 4-10. The most-picked team won 4 of 14 games with a result.
  • Most popular pick: Detroit Lions, picked by 92% of players (they won).
  • Biggest upset: New England Patriots, a 7.5 point underdog, beat Buffalo Bills, even though 91% of players picked Buffalo Bills.
  • Closest call: Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Seattle Seahawks, split 46% to 54%.

Every Week 5 game

Sorted by kickoff. The favorite is shown with its points, like −3.5. The bar shows the percentage of players who picked the more popular team.

GameMost pickedPickedResult
San Francisco 49ers vs. Los Angeles Rams −6.5Los Angeles Rams 84%
84%✗ LostUnderdog won
Minnesota Vikings −3.5 vs. Cleveland BrownsMinnesota Vikings 78%
78%✓ Won
Las Vegas Raiders vs. Indianapolis Colts −6.5Indianapolis Colts 90%
90%✓ Won
NY Giants vs. New Orleans Saints −1.5NY Giants 67%
67%✗ Lost
Dallas Cowboys −2.5 vs. NY JetsDallas Cowboys 76%
76%✓ Won
Denver Broncos vs. Philadelphia Eagles −3.5Philadelphia Eagles 86%
86%✗ LostUnderdog won
Miami Dolphins −1.5 vs. Carolina PanthersMiami Dolphins 57%
57%✗ LostUnderdog won
Houston Texans −1.5 vs. Baltimore RavensBaltimore Ravens 64%
64%✗ Lost
Tennessee Titans vs. Arizona Cardinals −7.5Arizona Cardinals 88%
88%✗ LostUnderdog won
Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Seattle Seahawks −3.5Seattle Seahawks 54%
54%✗ LostUnderdog won
Detroit Lions −10.5 vs. Cincinnati BengalsDetroit Lions 92%
92%✓ Won
Washington Commanders vs. Los Angeles Chargers −2.5Los Angeles Chargers 78%
78%✗ LostUnderdog won
New England Patriots vs. Buffalo Bills −7.5Buffalo Bills 91%
91%✗ LostUnderdog won
Kansas City Chiefs −3.5 vs. Jacksonville JaguarsKansas City Chiefs 82%
82%✗ LostUnderdog won

Beat the Spread picks

57 entries play in Beat the Spread leagues, picking which team will beat the spread instead of picking the winner. Their most popular picks went 5-9 this week.

GameMost pickedPickedBeat the spread?
San Francisco 49ers vs. Los Angeles Rams −6.5Los Angeles Rams 84%
84%✗ No
Minnesota Vikings −3.5 vs. Cleveland BrownsMinnesota Vikings 67%
67%✓ Yes
Las Vegas Raiders vs. Indianapolis Colts −6.5Indianapolis Colts 70%
70%✓ Yes
NY Giants vs. New Orleans Saints −1.5NY Giants 63%
63%✗ No
Dallas Cowboys −2.5 vs. NY JetsDallas Cowboys 84%
84%✓ Yes
Denver Broncos vs. Philadelphia Eagles −3.5Philadelphia Eagles 65%
65%✗ No
Miami Dolphins −1.5 vs. Carolina PanthersMiami Dolphins 63%
63%✗ No
Houston Texans −1.5 vs. Baltimore RavensBaltimore Ravens 57%
57%✗ No
Tennessee Titans vs. Arizona Cardinals −7.5Arizona Cardinals 58%
58%✗ No
Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Seattle Seahawks −3.5Tampa Bay Buccaneers 56%
56%✓ Yes
Detroit Lions −10.5 vs. Cincinnati BengalsDetroit Lions 82%
82%✓ Yes
Washington Commanders vs. Los Angeles Chargers −2.5Los Angeles Chargers 77%
77%✗ No
New England Patriots vs. Buffalo Bills −7.5Buffalo Bills 65%
65%✗ No
Kansas City Chiefs −3.5 vs. Jacksonville JaguarsKansas City Chiefs 79%
79%✗ No

The 2025-26 season

In the 2025-26 season, the team picked by the most players has won 178 of 271 games (66%). See the 2025-26 NFL Season pick trends for the crowd's favorite teams, overrated and underrated teams and the crowd's record each week.

Other weeks

Play along

The NFL Season pool is free, with no ads. Play weekly or all season, on your own or in a league with your friends. Want an edge? Read our NFL Season pick'em strategy guide. For the whole season, see the 2025-26 NFL Season pick trends.

This web site is for entertainment purposes only. Terms of Use Privacy Statement
poolsbyround.com is not affiliated in any way with the NFL, NBA, WNBA, NHL, NCAA, MLB or FIFA. All team names and logos are copyright of their respective owners.